Wich should be used?

My brother and I have a dilema.
We made two sigs to use on our account on another forum, but we don't have judges to decide wich is better so we would like you to chose one.

First:
http://i63.servimg.com/u/f63/13/53/54/17/protot11.png

Second:
http://i63.servimg.com/u/f63/13/53/54/17/protot12.png

The first is of better quality but the text is bad, would consider adding the text from the 2nd to the first sig instead ;)

I thank you for the great idea! Let's see who wins.

i agree with radillac 100 % :p

I prefer the first one as the second one seems of lower quality wich makes it hard to see what the render actually is. The lighting/text on the first one somewhat annoy me tho... it's as if that bright spot was added there just for the sake of having some form of light.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Aether

I prefer the first one as the second one seems of lower quality wich makes it hard to see what the render actually is. The lighting/text on the first one somewhat annoy me tho... it's as if that bright spot was added there just for the sake of having some form of light.

---

We already came to that conclusion, it will be changed.

Yup agree with Rad :)

Vote please XD

Bump-y

First version updated, better lighting, better text :)
http://i63.servimg.com/u/f63/13/53/54/17/protot13.png

i voted for nr 1 because off the quallity. but.. actualy nr 1 is chaotic. nr 2 has way better compo and flow. just needs better quallity and sexy lightning.

#1 for though it's a bit to messy.