Darksiders and Prototype-My Best

http://i974.photobucket.com/albums/a...Darksiders.png http://i974.photobucket.com/albums/a.../Prototype.png

I made darksiders first and then used the same idea for the prototype.

CnC please?

I really think these are my best

Holy...

Wow man. I can't even think of criticism.

thanks haha.

Always looking to improve so need all opinions. Good or bad.

Thanks for the compliment though (:

Look really good, I'm just going to mention that there's a lot going on, but it doesn't draw my attention away from the focal so really no complaints. kiu man, impressed.

On the darksiders one i think the focal doesn't stick out like the prototype one, maybe bring the render up a few layers and make it pop more.
The prototype one is pretty good, looks a lot like cs4pro's if you know what i mean :D
good job on both though

I like the one on the right more. The one on the left doesn't have a clear focal one, like Andrew said.

Not much of a fan of the Darksiders one, mainly because I'm not a fan of the render altogether, but the Prototype one is great. :)
I like the foreground effects of it and there's a lot going on, while none of it is distracting.
Keep it up.

Dont like darksiders, the blur at the bottom throws the whole thing off for me. The prototype one has nice effects though. Keep it up.

darksiders one is pretty cool... i dont really have much to say about it :/ sorry lol.

but the prototype one is very nice. good depth and great effects. only thing i would fix is the top left of the tag, it needs to be darkened a bit to keep with the depth perception youve created

I don't really like thee darksiders one as well. It's nice tag but compare it to your prototype one then it doesn't compare. As ratchetnclank said the blur at the bottom throws it off. Also the prototype does look extremely close to cs4pro's prototype sig

Nice work though it 10times better than what I can do

Can i see the original stock for the prototype one?

so people think I ripped it..

The renders were really good IMO and had a lot going on in them so that's why I chose them. I doubt I could of done this with a different render.

If people still don't believe me I will willingly upload the PSD

I never said you ripped it. I'm asking for the original image on your Prototype sig.
Because I've seen that same render on a stock and tbh it looks like you didn't do anything for the sig itself.
Thats why I asked for the original stock.

http://i27.tinypic.com/99m6xl.png cs4pro's http://i974.photobucket.com/albums/a.../Prototype.png slayerplayer's


I think they are just saying it is very similar in proportion and style, not ripped. good work, definately agree with above comments about the blur, and like the prototype one better imo. keep goin and make more of this style its working out for you.

Buckley: Here's the image that your asking for http://planetrenders.net/renders/dis...ed&cat=0&pos=1

Slayer: I was referring to the style of the sig. If you look at them both you can see the style is pretty much similar.

na his is way better.

I'm still nooby and as I said. It's a great render to use.

My fav from you Josh. Kiu.