Knight sig

[Godden]

posted this and edited it loads and on different sites u guys think its nice? how can i get better?



Version 2

[Fur]

i like v2...try a one pix boarder black looks better, the text needs work and in v2 take out the scanlines they dont look that good imo

[LoganGFX]

i personally like v1 better(coloring), but with v2's darker areas. Totally agree about the border/scanlines. Also, that blocky pattern should go on a permanent vacation:P
Not a fan of the text, especially so big and noticeable. try at least coloring the text to match the sig.


I know this sounds like a lot of bashing, but its not, really. This could be a nice sig, with some tweaks.

[GimpyThePirate17]

Personally, I like V2 with the scanlines. I think it gives it a sort of different atmosphere then what you usually see. It makes in stand out a little bit more. The block pattern is nice, but it makes my eyes wander away form the render. The border would be better if it were just black, like fur mentioned. The text also could use work. Pretty good job overall. 7/10

[tunafish69]

i personally like v1 better(coloring), but with v2's darker areas. Totally agree about the border/scanlines. Also, that blocky pattern should go on a permanent vacation:P
Not a fan of the text, especially so big and noticeable. try at least coloring the text to match the sig.


I know this sounds like a lot of bashing, but its not, really. This could be a nice sig, with some tweaks.

I second everything you just said.

[Godden]

so basically overall feeling is that v2 is better but border and text neeed work?

[tunafish69]

Yes.

[Daemon]

As the other said go woth a 1 px border. Also dont make the text that obvious