2 Images, One Winner, alot of Frustration

[dudesareus]

Me and my buddy made a couple images, and had our clan vote on them. They all chose his because of the characters used but would like people with gfx skills to vote ><

Mine:

His:

[Mitx]

Well, what i would say, is yours is better, why? the format, the effects, the text placement, but the text could be a little bit more visible..