another sig ok 4 versions which is best?

[Xoligy]

ok which out of these four do you think is the best and i should use?

original


filmgrain


cross hatched


diffused glow


personnally i like the original and filmgrain one lol but any feed back is welcome!

[Jelan]

eh the 1st the rest are just filters but you're border is way off...just select ya sig the edit stroke 1 pixel black inside or outside..

[Xoligy]

ok cheers for the feed back i'll do it when i get home

[MiNdFrEaK]

meh, i dont really like any of them but if i had to choose it would be the 2nd one. the grain looks kinda cool. but yea needs work.

[Dr D-Mento]

yeah, if any, then the second. THe rest are too much in my eyes (not meaning it hurts them, but that's just the way I see it...)...

[B][G K]

i'd say the first one because it's the cleanest and doesn't look like you slapped some random filter on it. try making one good one before you post 4 of the same thing with different filters. can't you tell that the filter on the 4th one kills the overall quality of the sig? it's a decent sig, buttrust your own judgement, then take feedback and see how your decision turned out. it's the best way to learn and get better.

[Xoligy]

i'll have another go at it again tonight then