Need your opinions!!!!!!!

[Hit A Switch]

Which one is the best, and how can i improve that one, please include a lot of detail in your posts i'm a photoshop noob
Thanks
1.


2.


3.


4.


5.


6.

[-MM.Kritez]

1 is better. this has a lot of potential, its well setup, but you havent really went the distance with this yet. adding a lighting source and some more effects, as well as some text would all elevate this alot. If you having trouble with those, or need some advice sent me a PM i have a few good ideas for this piece

[Papa]

First is for sure the best. i liekt eh darkend bg. I liek the smudgign and colors.

I think you should work on adding more c4d's next time, and also adding more clipping masks!

Overall though dude your looking good so far. I like what you are demonstrating and you have a lot of potentail. keep up the good work.

Maybe add text next time?

[Hit A Switch]

Thanks a lot for the feedback guys appreciate it a lot!

I've tryed to improve it by adding clipping masks. However im unsure if it looks better or worse.

Your thoughts?

[dub]

I like the new first one better, I think its lacking some lighting. that will add a lot of depth imo.
great effects in the sig tho man.

[Hit A Switch]

Thanks for your comments, I've tryed to add some lighting what do you guys think?