Hayley Williams

[Manga]

Thinking of removing the lighting but I think it sort of compliments the way her arms are. I might hue it.

[Helix]

Background lighting doesn't seem to match the lighting on the render. Try to create shadows where they should be and keep the lightsource in mind. Realism is your goal

[Manga]

Lighting still doesn't match very well IMO.

[Casey]

i think v2 is better, I think at this point the lighting really isnt going to match but just keep playing with it. I wish you would get rid of the brick wall on the left as its really not cohesive with the rest of the tag along with the text, which seems like an after thought. Also, watch out for noise? or whatever is overlayed on top of your stock image. digging the blue/oranges

[Manga]

i think v2 is better, I think at this point the lighting really isnt going to match but just keep playing with it. I wish you would get rid of the brick wall on the left as its really not cohesive with the rest of the tag along with the text, which seems like an after thought. Also, watch out for noise? or whatever is overlayed on top of your stock image. digging the blue/oranges

That's my C4D.

[Helix]

You made it worse with v2, get rid of the overcontrasted balls of light and redo the lighting layer by layer. First one is better with the effects.

[Manga]

You made it worse with v2, get rid of the overcontrasted balls of light and redo the lighting layer by layer. First one is better with the effects.

Je ne sais pas. The 2nd one feels like it is cleaner.

[Carso]

I love the lighing on urs it looks good
over all 8/10 Minds not as good as urs