Progress

[Sioux]

This was a quick signature I did with a semi cut render of a Magic the Gathering card. I don't know if the guy I made it for will like it but I have gotten a couple small compliments so I am happy. Though, some CnC would be great.




I shamelessly admit I was inspired by a handful of you advanced folks around here making signatures like this so I figured I should try some humble pie and go outside my comfort zone. Once more, some CnC would be appreciated.



After tinkering enough with this I think it came out nicely. Once again my gut says the text is unneeded or simply doesn't fit this signature but I did it anyways. I don't know. I think I am making progress. CnC, Pleaseasaurus.

[Liquid]

if the first one had textures it would be pretty cool , right now its a little dull imo , 2nd is over saturated , nice ones kiu

[Sioux]

A little more progress.

[JDragon]

You're definitely showing a good deal of progress, the first one is good but with some grunge work or rust textures I think it could of bumped it up a bit like Liquid said.

Second you need to really watch the layers and the effects on the overall image since brightness = high contrast. If you can keep it even much better result.

Third one is probably the best one out of the bunch.

As far as the other new ones go, I'm not liking them much, you seem to do much better with a smaller canvas then a large one. kiu

[Vicious Zen]

you're clearly showing progress.
Third one is clearly the best of the bunch. I'd tighten up the gap in the two rows of text though.