made this for a friend..

[Haven]

what you guys think..? give me a rating between 1 and 2 please thanks a bunch! :P *my rating is top to bottom = worst to best*







http://myfilebucket.com/u/haven/31.gif

tell me what you guys think...remember rate between 1 and 2!

[tabloid]

between one and two?
which one am I rating and is one good or bad?

cmon man help me out here lol

[Nightfire]

[First] Text does not go with sig, figures in background are faded to much.

[Second] Text does not go with sig, needs border and the flower blue sun thing doesn't fit halo.

[Third] "The Missing Link" text doesn't fit, but the text in the white fits very well, the text to the bottom left should be smaller and I think to change the font of it to a more standard font. Otherwise I quite like this one, maybe a pixel border.

Good job on them overall though.

um sry not much of a rater person but I would say the 3rd is the best.

[Edit] Fourth: Didn't see this one, This one's really nice with great animation ideas and text. I would suggest making the animation longer since it's sorta stuttery, and you really need a border, pixel would do fine. I'd say this is equal to your third.

[2-intenze]

if i must choose b'tween 1 and 2 i will choose 1, not cuz the sigs are ugly but cuz te sigs just aren't perfect, in all the sigs the stroke of the text is to big and all the 3 sigs needs a black 1 px boarder (stroke inside)

[Haven]

you can't say that the "flower blue sun thing" doesn't come from Halo...since it actually is from Halo 2..its the stick medal...and sorry if my sigs aren't "te perfect" I'm actually fairly new to photoshop and go by the tutorials...so..the rating was a joke...rate whatever...