Rate the signature above you.

[Nightfire]

5/10
It seems as though there wasn't much thought put into the creation of the vectors in this piece. Pretty much all of them just look like a circle that you took a chunk out of to make a moon :P. The bg reminds me of old style fractals or grunge brushes. Also your text really doesn't fit, more like slapped on with a drop shadow.

- A creative way you could do your text, since this is a vector styled piece, is use some unique vector designs to create your text.

your second: 5/10
I don't know if you chose to or not but your render doesn't look like it has been cut out properly. I can still see it surrounded by a white thin line. And if you did chose to it just looks bad XD.

The design the the bottom left corner should also be removed since it doesn't enhance anything and just draws away from your focal point since it's brighter than anything else in your sig besides the bit of red on the hand. The lighting also seems off, the light source on your render seems to be coming from the bottom, yet you have your lighting on the bg coming from the top.

The circle that repeats your render's head next to your text doesn't really do anything, IMO it would go better with just the text. Also moving the text a little ways away from the right side would help balance things out since it almost touches the side of your sig.

lol and sorry, I hate just rating sigs since that doesn't teach you much, and I think I went a bit overboard on a few things since I haven't posted in quite some time :P.

[Bloodtears]

1: 4/10
Text is kinda hard to read, remove the scanlines and it looks like the whole image is just made out of spatter...

2: 1/10
What is that?
no srsly.. userbar?

Sry if I was too cruel, listening to KoRn - Break some off x)

Come on, papa!
Post so I can have sex with your halo sig, I r horny at it

[Duncan]

Love it. both 8/10

[Bloodtears]

1st: Well, the sunshine is too bright, I'd remove the squares, added a gradient map and also, I would have used preset fonts... 4/10

2nd: well, borders r f*ckt up (soz if that hurt you), lower scanline opacity, the brushing is blurred and for god's sake! use preset fonts... 5/10

[SickSan]

7/10 both.

[Jeff]

6.5 - nice clean colors, but the text stands out too much.
7 - like the colors here as well, and fitting text this time. nice job.

next dude, no need to rate now listening to unless you want you, just state which random one you're rating.

[Tooms]

6/10 -Too much going on with text for me but good overall

7.5/10 - nice depth and lighting

[Bloodtears]

7.5/10 Enchantment: Nice colors, leaves, depth..
Bad motion blur, text..


5/10 Launch: Well, I liked it a bit at first.. well..
its just regular colors, reduced opacity and rly bad borders..

[Daemon]

7/10. it have a good depth and a nice bg so good job
4/10 i Dont like this to much it looks like his head is just poppin out from nowhere

[aivwaras]

8.5/10 Good depth, nice colors (I don't know whi I didnt give 9, or even 10. Probably I dont want to be very generous)
8.4/10 I liked the 1st one's render more, but again, good colors, depth...