.: Diamond :.

Here's why:
Contrast - Nice
Brushing - Nice
Text - Could use some work but overall pretty good

Baller

Here's why not:
Brushing - Not nice <---sorry
Contrast - None
Sizing - Weird sizing on it
Color - Not too font of what you did
Text - Horrible font and horrible color on the pixel font

Overall Scores

.: Diamond :. - 9.5/10
Baller - 5/10