The duplication between the left and right side is very evident, which is typically a bit repelling. Clearly the style you were going for was messy so I cannot give you as many critisisms as I could assuming you want to maintain that style (I lean towards a clean/simple style). I don't like the typography because, in my book, typography is always better when you follow the simpler route. Id take off the texture, bevel, and pick a simpler font. Then, it wouldn't quite match the rest would it? Again back to my point of how I lean towards simplicity. The border isn't extremely attractive. I see you were trying something different, but I dont think, aesthetically, this is the right choice. With so much content packed into such a small canvas size, the eyes are left to wander while one searches for the subject and/or focal point.