Oh. My. God. I love the top one... I'd say 9/10. I'm seeing a bit of "over-topazing" on the render, but thats just me... otherwise, I love it sooo muchespecially the text!
2nd one is just as nice but I think the text is a little big and there are some spots on the left side with (I think) a little too much sharpening/topaz. Otherwise great, 8/10