Rate the signature above you.

[†john316†™]

hmm
5/10
6/10

[ratchetnclank]

I've always liked that sig with the tree its so eyecatching. 9/10

[KidBuu]

9/10 thats areal good sig man everytime i look at it i admire it lol
8/10 the light source istoo bright

[BonesMa]

7/10 c4ds seem to much but I like what you have done
7/10 again with the c4ds sorry and size is a bit big but nice tag though

[SSSSK]

wow beautiful topaz and render and background 8, 9 if it had text

[KidBuu]

6/10 nothing extra ordinary
8/10 i like the smoke effects

[SSSSK]

1. 5/10 has nice flow but text is a letdown
render could do with cleaning and sharpening
erase some of the c4d(s)

2. 7/10 has nice in and out flow
again text is a bit better could do with some working
make some parts darker to put a light focus on the render
on the render there is an obvious bubble c4d that would could change
nice effects though

[†john316†™]

hmm
can't say i really like the far left hand corner at all
but other than that i do like this piece

nice lighting and feel to it

but i would like to see the original pic to see fully what you did
so i wont rate it yet

as for the 2nd
i actually kinda like it lol
intriguing style
8/10

[KidBuu]

8/10
um dont know that smudge doesnt look like clouds. BUT that lightning is awsome

[CyberShot]

1st one:
8/10 love it just txt needs improving
2nd:
Not to keen on
don't like how his hair is so white and his face you should have erased parts covering his face
good text though
6/10