um i dont think any one of them looks better then the other
the reason is those bubbles, they are erupting out of no where and unneccesary covering up the image.
what are they doing there in the first place.
i think you thought that since its a n industrial chaos u make the lp chaotic? but its not chaotic for me its messy for me
the girl with the metal wings? they are nice but poorbly blended and covered up by c4d's
the dark and grungyness looks good here but i did suggest u to remove that bubbles