Rate the signature above you.

[Kaoz]

Hello, I'm new to Photoshop (Ive been using it for a week now, and not too much) but Id really like to know some constructive criticism on my signature. I made it following Freek's Style Tutorial (known as Seemliss on this forum). Any tips and help would be really appreciated.

Thanks!

[madara]

8/10 i dont like the black lines in the render

[mastergfx291]

10/10 tht animation is awesum

[Samii]

1/10. I'm sorry but i really don't like it. I looks like the images on the left and the right have just been plonked there without any thought, and they don't really match the rest of the image. Also, the font is terrible.
xx

[Ascarine]

3/10 lol this isnt because i don't like the sig its cos A) it looks like she has a fish hook in her mouth so bed choice of stock and B) because of that really annoying square in the top left. Would also say turn down the patterned background.

[Dron]

4/10 - that light spot kills it, too vivid imho and effect looks kinda low quality mm

[mastergfx291]

10/10

i like the tanks and soldier they luk gd bud.

[+s9.Oath]

2/10
its original but bad compostion needs alot of work

[Ascarine]

7/10 lol as i said before it looks like Mavins being crushed by crystal which i like but it looks odd (slightly, thats just me being petty though)

[mastergfx291]

8/10 i lyk the light and da lines coming off him