One of My First Sigs.

[|Sky]

it is in my sig.

[cs4pro]

That a nice sig mate
Blending is awsome. Cool smudging.
I think the right side of the sig is too bright.
I would crop the sig up a bit.
The size is a bit weird so I would remove a piece of the right side

The text needs work.
Make it a bit bigger and move it closer to your focal point.
If the text won't succeed, then just dont put text in it.

Effects are nice

GJ sky
Keep it up

[Kaka11|LFC]

This is really good for one of your first sigs, I was horrible when I first started and still aren't that good.

Its a bit wide though, not really proportional to the height but thats cool, it all depends on what you want. You've blended the focal with the bg well, I like this, its nice and simple, not over complicated or anything.

[Zomgshanked]

Wow, for one of your first signatures this is beastly. Good Job and the criticism I agree with CS4Pro on. Great job overall, though. Keep it up. =]

[Takken]

I agree with cs4. I think the lighting is too strong however, also I wouldn't put the source there. Work on your composition and contrast.

[|Sky]

That a nice sig mate
Blending is awsome. Cool smudging.
I think the right side of the sig is too bright.
I would crop the sig up a bit.
The size is a bit weird so I would remove a piece of the right side

The text needs work.
Make it a bit bigger and move it closer to your focal point.
If the text won't succeed, then just dont put text in it.

Effects are nice

GJ sky
Keep it up

yeh i tried a few different texts,
but they all failed...lol.
so i just made it extremely simple.
thanks for the critiques!

[Downfall]

Very nice for a first sig i deleted mine it was that bad xD i used to just crop and add text :P