Anime sig

[loghan]

Is it good for beginner?

[Dennis.]

It is great for a beginner

The background fits well, and the colours are nice.
I would bring the text closer to the focal, maybe to about here:

Im not the best at text but you get the idea.

Not really liking the pen tool around the blade, you should add some other effect. Aswell as adding more effects to the tag.
Most of my advise for this is the same as the advice found in your other thread:
http://www.gfxvoid.com/forums/showthread.php?t=63488

[Vicious Zen]

Is it good for beginner?

It's not bad. Little too monotone for my tastes, and is kinda plain. Could use some more effects, and whatever that is floating in from the top right is really distracting.

[loghan]

Thanks for the comment. Another opinions?