Rate the signature above you.

[Doodle]

7/10
Everything is blended really well, not bad depth, but it's missing a light source.

6/10
Think the render needs to be blended in more, and the colors in the bg don't match the colors of the render.

[Monroe]

8/10
I like this one a lot. Very different style than what I usually see.

7/10
I like the creativeness but I'm not feelin the colors too much.

[Necrothalass]

8/10 now that i actually know what you've done with it

[DR809]

8/10 The effects could be more vibrant
Flow is nice and nice colors going on.

[DJFX]

1.)9/10- not feeling the text so much, 2.)9/10- same thing

[Necrothalass]

10/10 that is so amazing, made the sig grungey like the game yet colorful that is really awesome.

[|Sky]

8/10,
As stated before, the colours could be a tad more vibrant,
But its really good.

[Pulse III]

8/10

The effects are nice. Depth is good. The text kills it for me though.

[Cap'n Jazz]

7/10. Pretty cool.

[Monroe]

To be honest, all I'm seeing is 7-9/10. And there's no way that everyone's sigs are equally impressive. I think we're all being a little too nice to each other. So allow me to be brutally honest without labeling me an asshole

If 5/10 is average, anything less being below average, anything higher being above average, I would give the above sig a 6/10.

It's definitely more impressive than what the average newcomer to Photoshop can achieve, but it has a lot of qualities that look noobish to me. Not a bad sig at all though.