Rate the signature above you.

[DR809]

6/10
i personally dont like it and feel some spots might be over sharpened and the lighting feels weird. Colors are nice though and text is a bit meh.

[Aether]

1st - 8.5/10 - Great effects, lighting and depth, not giving it a 9 because I expect you to improve even further
2nd - 7.5/10 - Would've been a solid 8 but the brown smudge at the bottom is just ... 1 colour wich in my opinion doesn't work well in this tag.. throw some of the clipping masks on there and it's win.

[furbz]

7.5/10

Needs better blending, the effects are kind of standoutish.

[Cap'n Jazz]

10/10. One of my favorite sigs of all time.
7/10. Eh... Not so much.

[TRUeLM]

6/10 : It has good flow, but thats about it. The colors throw me off...

[Fur]

10/10 for render :P

Really a 6/10 the render doesnt fit the BG IMO

[Bogui]

6/10

[Cap'n Jazz]

8/10. Really cool.

[xxB3ASTxx]

1/10 no offense

[Derosion]

1/10 no offense

You can't give a 1/10 and not criticize why.

6/10. Monotone and it's lacking effects, it's also very plain, which I guess ties in with the lacking effects.