That is pretty cool XD
Copycat 2 looks very similar, the whole atmosphere is near the same
but some effects are missing, especially the lighter near the horns and the font's are different ~
Copycat 1the splatters are pretty much spot on, the right side doesn't look like it has the same effects though, the colour is slightly different and it's missing the main texturey/sharpish feeling
I'm going with copycat 2 ~