Rate the signature above you.

@joey
7/10
not digging the text

Really like the top one, not much else i can say on it how to improve it.
I like the second one too, good job on both.. :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Joey x

Dude, that doesn't make any sense. I used more topaz in the second one.
The first one was a low strength topaz on 67%.

The second one was left at 100%.

@DR

8.5/10
Lighting needs work and the C4D is a bit too big, but really nice otherwise.

7/10
Not digging the text, major downfall for me.

---

I didn't say you used less, I said it was more forgiving, probably because the render is bigger.

3.5/10 Not much going on here.

8/10,
Like I said before

so good i love this style
9/10

Needs more blending.

4/10

7/10, i like the button

9/10. Fucking sick, but the lighting/colors could be a little better.
8/10. Still very nice. Cool text, but not digging the topaz so much.

Edit: whoops someone beat me to it.
For RunningMan: 6.5/10 There's lots of flow but I feel it's overdone, not a big fan of this.

7.9/10
its a cool tag

6/10
i personally dont like it and feel some spots might be over sharpened and the lighting feels weird. Colors are nice though and text is a bit meh.

1st - 8.5/10 - Great effects, lighting and depth, not giving it a 9 because I expect you to improve even further:)
2nd - 7.5/10 - Would've been a solid 8 but the brown smudge at the bottom is just ... 1 colour wich in my opinion doesn't work well in this tag.. throw some of the clipping masks on there and it's win.

7.5/10

Needs better blending, the effects are kind of standoutish.

10/10. One of my favorite sigs of all time.
7/10. Eh... Not so much.

6/10 : It has good flow, but thats about it. The colors throw me off...

10/10 for render :P

Really a 6/10 the render doesnt fit the BG IMO

6/10

8/10. Really cool.

1/10 no offense

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by xxB3ASTxx

1/10 no offense

---

You can't give a 1/10 and not criticize why.

6/10. Monotone and it's lacking effects, it's also very plain, which I guess ties in with the lacking effects.

7/10 - Cool effects, I've tried a similar style once but failed to fill up the negative space unlike you:)

4/10.
5/10. I love Ratchet. <3

8/10 :) its awesome.

both are awsome and unique :D 8/10 for both :D

9/10.
So sick, man.

8/10
IMO its under contrasted and text needs a little work

9/10 Epic man. o.o

The black and white doesnt do it justice and the light source is placed incorrectly. Effects feel lq imo. 5/10

both awesome 1st 9/10 2nd 10/10

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DR809

The black and white doesnt do it justice and the light source is placed incorrectly. Effects feel lq imo. 5/10

---

The effects are lq. I blurred them. o.o

And 9/10

8/10
i love it ;)

DAMM <3
U got some sick usage of C4D's right there.
bigger C4D whore then ketg? probably :>
8/10
9/10
Really sick!

ahahahaha xD poor ketgy, if he read this ^^
9/10 [ Love the style ]
8/10 [ yeaaaaaaaaaaaaaah its snowing!!!!! XD ]

both smexy,
8/10
9/10
^^.

good lighting, good text, good depth, what more can i say ._.
8.5/10
thats one creepy render e.e

8/10
The head to the right looks kinda awkward, but I really like the composition of the whole thing. :]

9/10 The lighting is nice, and the animation really tops it off ^^

6/10 nice effects bit LQ and it looks abit under contrasted

7/10

It looks a bit under contrasted and iron man looks a bit over sharpened. The light near the text is a bit over powering.

Rate this sig,
http://i55.tinypic.com/2q1wdid.jpg

4.5/10

Too messy.

9.5/10