Gears

[Atelier]

Look pretty slick. Please do me a favor and change the fractal on the top to orange and red though. The yellow and magenta is driving me crazy on the rest of the sig. :P Also, where the black space on the left and right is, keep making it darker towards the edges. It looks to flat at those points.

[Pigler]

Plain and looks like you basically did nothing (and I hope thats not the border). The render also looks too blurry&low quality in my opinion.

kiu

[Derosion]

Plain and looks like you basically did nothing (and I hope thats not the border). The render also looks too blurry&low quality in my opinion.

kiu

It's a manipulation, read OP.

OT - It's a bit dull imo, but good job on manipulating him in there.

[Pigler]

Sure it is I'm just saying its nothing special.

[Allseeyineye]

Plain and looks like you basically did nothing (and I hope thats not the border). The render also looks too blurry&low quality in my opinion.

kiu

lol, isn't that the point of such a manip?
If it looks like he has just placed a stock and a border, he's done a great job blending in the render and such

Sure it is I'm just saying its nothing special.

It is, you try to make such a manip

[Derosion]

Sure it is I'm just saying its nothing special.

You're entitled to your own opinion, so I won't say anymore, but by having a lot of things doesn't make a tag better, it's only the final outcome that really matters .

[Pigler]

He didn't do basically anything ugh :|

. The guy in the front is a render. The background is just a stock altough I changed some things in the background but oh well.

[cs4pro]

He didn't do basically anything ugh :|

. The guy in the front is a render. The background is just a stock altough I changed some things in the background but oh well.

Well creating lightning, depht, blending and gradients is nothgin to you. then it's fine to me.

Just stop the discussion and stay on topic. I don't want this to become a flaming threat or w/e. Everybody has his own opinion. Leave it like that.